Unit 2 of Conflict of Laws (syllabus: Module II — the bases on which a court takes jurisdiction in a case with a foreign element, forum non conveniens and anti-suit injunctions, and the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments). Below: what the unit covers, the provisions it turns on, and the cases an examiner expects you to name.
What this unit covers
- What does jurisdiction mean in this subject, who may sue, and who is immune from suit?
- What is the difference between a judgment in rem and a judgment in personam, and are judgments in rem really binding on all the world?
- What does actor sequitur forum rei mean, and is a judgment given without personal jurisdiction a nullity?
- On what grounds does a court take jurisdiction in personam, and how does the Indian scheme differ from the English?
- How does an Indian court exercise admiralty jurisdiction in rem over a vessel?
- When will a court that has jurisdiction refuse to exercise it?
- Why are foreign judgments enforced at all, and on what grounds may recognition be resisted at common law?
- How is a foreign judgment given effect in India, and what are the two routes?
Treat that list as a self-test: recite each topic's rule from memory before you open its cases.
Provisions
- Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s. Sections 83 and 86
- Indian Evidence Act 1872, now the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023, s. Sections 41 and 44, now section 35
- Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s. Section 20
- Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s. Sections 16, 19 and 20
- Admiralty (Jurisdiction and Settlement of Maritime Claims) Act 2017, s. Sections 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 17
- Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s. Sections 10 and 151
- Code of Civil Procedure 1908, s. Sections 2(5), 2(6), 13, 14 and 44A
Leading cases
- The Christina and Trendtex Trading Corporation v. Central Bank of Nigeria
- Satya v. Teja Singh
- Sirdar Gurdyal Singh v. The Rajah of Faridkot
- Maharani of Baroda v. Wildenstein
- Williams v. Jones
- Marine Geotechniques v. Coastal Marine Construction & Engineering Ltd.
Full case summaries
- Sirdar Gurdyal Singh v. The Rajah of Faridkot
- Williams v. Jones (1845)
- Abouloff v. Oppenheimer
- Sankaran Govindan v. Lakshmi Bharathi
- Government of India v. Taylor
- Ohem Abheong v. Mahomed Rowther (1946)
- Lalji Raja & Sons v. Hansraj Nathu Ram
- Maharani of Baroda v. Wildenstein
- Carvatho v. Hullblyth Angola
- Godard v. Gray
- Carl Zeiss v. Rayner & Keeler
- Carrick v. Hancock
- S.A. Consortium v. Sun and Sand
- Re Dulles' Settlements
- Sadler v. Robins
- Vadala v. Lawes
- The Duchess of Kingston's Case
- Re Macartney
- Crawley v. Issacs
- Mallappa Yellappa v. Raghavendra
- I&G Investment Trust v. Raja of Khalikote
- Marine Geotechniques v. Coastal Marine Construction & Engineering Ltd.
- R. Viswanathan v. Rukn-ul-Mulk Syed Abdul Majid
- Parkasho v. Singh
- Dynamit Actien Gesellschaft v. Rio Tinto Zinc
- Huntington v. Attrill
- Banco de Vizcaya v. Don Alfonso